Milk Mustache, NY: Milkshakes at Brats in Chelsea


PB&J on the left, Milkaholic on the right [Photograph: Maggie Hoffman]

The milkshakes at Daniel Angerer's Austrian diner, Brats, are quick-melting—more frothy than thick—but unusual and delicious.

They're not enormous for $5.95, but the each shake showcases really good dairy. (And other substances, like tobacco, but we skipped that one. Sorry, kids.)

The PB&J is frothy, smooth, and impressively peanutty, like the interior of a peanut butter M&M, but you don't get any jelly flavor until you bite the crisp candied popcorn floating on top. We're ok with that; we didn't want globs of jelly in our shake anyway.

The Milkaholic is like chocolate milk you might make at home, except several times richer—and it's made with a blend of sheep's milk, goat's milk, cow's milk, and honey, with a chocolate swirl that mostly settles to the bottom. There's the slight tang, but this isn't a health-food yogurt drink. It's easily overpowered by Angerer's kraut-topped dogs, so you might want to order this on its own as an afternoon snack.


362 West 23rd Street, New York 10011 (near 9th Avenue, map)

Serious Eats Newsletters

Keep up with our latest recipes, tips, techniques and where to eat!


Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment: