Taste Test: Hot Chocolate Mixes

Slideshow SLIDESHOW: Taste Test: Hot Chocolate Mixes

[Photographs: Robyn Lee]

The Winners!

Best Cheap to Mid-Priced Mix: Ghirardelli

Runner-up: Lake Champlain

Best Fancy: Jacques Torres

Most Insanely Indulgent: Mariebelle

Since hot chocolate/cocoa is one of our favorite insides-warmers this chilly time of year, we set out to find the best. Now, first it should be clarified: hot chocolate and hot cocoa are not the same thing. Most of us are guilty of using the terms interchangeably, and probably will continue to even after this reading this...

A quick tutorial: Hot cocoa is made with cocoa powder, a byproduct of the chocolate-making process. Hot chocolate should contain actual chocolate!* We included both since, well, we'd be happy chugging back either. We tried a total of 17 brands, dividing them into two main categories, depending on price: cheap-to-mid range, and the more fancypants (76 cents or more per ounce). Some called for water, others for milk; we followed the instructions exactly on the packaging.

* Lake Champlain's "Hot Chocolate" mix, for example, contains cocoa powder but not real chocolate, so it's actually mislabeled.

Brands We Tried

Cheap to Mid-Priced (Made with water): Nestle, Hershey's, Swiss Miss, Trader Joe's, Whole Foods 365, Land O'Lakes**.

**Land O'Lakes was right on the price range border, at 75 cents per ounce.

Cheap to Mid-Priced (Made with milk): Ghirardelli, Lake Champlain, Allegro, Nesquick.

Fancy (Made with milk): Jacques Torres, Mariebelle, Williams-Sonoma, Green and Black, Scharffen Berger, E. Guittard, Dagoba.

20101209-127730-cocoa-tasting-table.jpg

Note the proper cocoa-sipping ear gear at the back left: ear muffs. Lookin' good, Jessica!

The Criteria

Whether hot chocolate or cocoa, it should be smooth and creamy, with a warm-the-insides richness. Not too sweet, slightly bitter (like good chocolate) with a velvety mouthfeel. If it's actual hot chocolate, it should taste like melted chocolate bits swirled with warm milk.

20101209-127730-cocoa-tasting-realcups.jpg

So many cocoa-crusted mugs.

Why the Losers Lost

Many of the mixes that called for hot water instead of milk tasted like diluted chocolate juice. "Weak sauce," noted tasters. Others were way too sweet, honey-like, and syrupy. Some finished with an acrid or just downright funky aftertaste.

20101209-127730-cocoa-tasting-cups.jpg

Our Favorites

20101211-taste-test-jacques-torres.jpg

Best Fancy (Made with milk): Jacques Torres This was like eating a melted chocolate bar, a really good dark one. "Would definitely drink a whole cup of this," agreed tasters. There's a half cup of milk per every 1/4 cup of mix (that's a whole 2-to-1 milk-to-chocolate ratio!), which contains solid chocolate nuggets mixed with the powder. It's definitely indulgent, but also very drinkable. Slightly salty to balance the sweetness. $18 for 18 ounces.

20101211-taste-test-ghiradelli.jpg

Best Cheap to Mid-Priced (Made with milk): Ghirardelli: This is another pick for the sweet-tooth type. It's chocolaty, with a blast of sweetness lingering in each sip. "Went back for more, and actually finished my whole cup, even with all the tasting samples," said one self-proclaimed sweets enthusiast. It has some depth, but not bitter or dark-tasting; definitely more on the milk chocolate end of the spectrum. This is what you should graduate to after Swiss Miss. $5.95 for 20 ounces.

Read more about the winners of all the categories here »

Have You Ever..


More Taste Tests

20101128-chickenstock-links.jpg

Comments

Add a comment

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment: