Ixcacao from Huckleberry Bar ($11)
Eggnog at Ward III ($12)
Ward III is also serving a perfect hot toddy and bourbon-spiked cider with whipped cream.
Brown Butter Old Fashioned at Gramercy Park Hotel's Rooftop Bar ($18)
Hot Buttered Rye from Rye ($8)
Koffie Van Brunt at Fort Defiance ($9)
Clement's Shrub at Prime Meats ($13)
Prime Meats also has a rotating hot punch available for $5. The one we tried was a soothing blend of brandy and bourbon, cloves, cider, honey, thyme, and rosemary.
The Deep Sea Diver from Hotel Delmano ($12)
Hotel Delmano: 82 Berry Street, Brooklyn, New York 11211 (map); 718-387-1945